The main themes of this episode are:
The decline of beauty in modern architecture and its societal impact: The sources argue that modern architecture, particularly Brutalism, has largely abandoned beauty in favor of functionality and a minimalist aesthetic. This shift reflects a broader cultural trend towards nihilism and the rejection of traditional values.
The psychological effects of architecture: The sources explore the impact of our built environment on human well-being. They contend that beautiful buildings and spaces positively affect our mental and physical health, while unattractive or sterile environments can induce stress and negativity.
Reclaiming beauty in architecture: The sources advocate for a return to beauty as a guiding principle in design, drawing upon historical examples and scientific evidence to support their argument.
"There is an answer to this rampant incivility. Don’t let governments and their egregious mismanagement of this crisis wreck your integrity, your capacity for love, your belief in rights, your aspirations for yourself and others. The only way to fight back against Brutalism is with freedom and beauty, and that begins in your own life." - The Return of Brutalism, The Atlas Society
Key Ideas & Facts
The Rise of Brutalism and the Rejection of Beauty:
The Atlas Society article connects the rise of Brutalism after World War II with a sense of societal nihilism and the rejection of the past. The article argues that the movement's focus on "temporality and functionality only" resulted in "ghastly government buildings" devoid of aesthetic appeal.
Tucker Carlson, in the excerpt from "The Ugly Truth About Postmodern Architecture," echoes this sentiment, claiming that postmodern architecture, of which Brutalism is a part, is "designed to demoralize and hurt you and destroy your spirit." He sees the lack of beauty in these structures as a reflection of a "sick and dark society."
"Brutalism […] is the movement that eventually gave us all the ghastly government buildings in the U.S. that were put up in the 60s through the 90s. They are concrete, sparse, and just slightly horrible to the eye because they are meant to be. It was a movement that rejected aesthetics." - The Return of Brutalism, The Atlas Society
Historical Context of Beauty:
The CASE article, "The Rise and Fall of Beauty in Western Culture," traces the historical evolution of beauty as a concept. In pre-modern times, beauty was intertwined with goodness and truth, reflecting a belief in a divinely ordered cosmos. This understanding, exemplified by structures like Kilpeck Church, viewed beauty as an objective quality, not merely subjective perception.
The Venetian Letter excerpt similarly highlights the historical shift in architectural values, noting how the classical emphasis on "precise rules" for beautiful buildings gave way to modernist prioritization of "originality and creativity," often at the expense of public appeal.
"What makes us and our dilemmas so very different from those of the medieval period is that medieval people—including the most brilliant intellectuals of those centuries—thought that beauty and goodness (like truth, and like being itself which was the reality in which all the others were grounded) were transcendental realities." - The Rise and Fall of Beauty in Western Culture, CASE
The Psychological Impact of Architecture:
The Venetian Letter piece delves into the scientific evidence demonstrating beauty's positive effects on human well-being. It cites studies showing how aesthetically pleasing environments improve mood, cognitive function, and even physical healing. Conversely, sterile or unattractive spaces can induce stress and discomfort.
Carlson also emphasizes this point, arguing that working in a "cube" with artificial lighting and no privacy sends the message that "you mean nothing, you are replaceable," contributing to a sense of dehumanization.
"Research shows that there is a pathway at the base of the brain that leads from the visual cortex to the parahippocampal place area, that is the brain region which responds strongly to visual scenes such as landscapes, cityscapes, and buildings. The nerve cells located along this pathway show an increased density of receptors for endorphins, which are the brain’s own pleasure molecules." - Venetian Letter
Reclaiming Beauty in Architecture:
All sources advocate for a return to beauty as a core principle in design. The CASE article suggests finding a balance between the purely subjective and the overly rigid, looking to artists like David Jones who capture beauty in the "messy, violent and enchanting world" through intricate details.
The Venetian Letter argues that beauty shouldn't be solely relegated to art galleries, but should be integrated into our everyday surroundings, from housing to hospitals, to improve individual and societal well-being.
Conclusion
The sources presented offer a compelling argument for the importance of beauty in the built environment. They trace the historical shift away from beauty in modern architecture and explore the negative social and psychological consequences of this change. Ultimately, they call for a renewed focus on beauty as a vital element in design, essential for human well-being and a flourishing society.
Share this post